| |
4 |
3 |
2 |
1 |
| Purpose |
The purpose of our bill is clear and comprehensive. We demonstrate extensive background knowledge of the issue. |
The purpose of our bill is clear. We demonstrate background knowledge of the issue. |
The purpose of our bill is fairly clear. We demonstrate basic background knowledge of the issue. |
The purpose of our bill is unclear. We demonstrate minimal background knowledge of the issue. |
| Format |
Our bill contains all required elements, including position, purpose, actions, definitions, and funding. All elements are in order. |
Our bill contains most elements, although some may be missing, incomplete, or incorrectly ordered. |
Our bill contains only a few of the required elements, or elements are largely incomplete. |
Our bill contains none of the required elements and is incomplete. |
| Recommendations |
Our bill demonstrates thoughtful analysis of the issue and recommends effective and affordable solutions based on the evidence gathered. |
Our bill demonstrates an analysis of the issue and recommends solutions that are effective and use the evidence gathered adequately but are cost-prohibitive. |
Our bill demonstrates a moderate level of analysis of the issue and recommends solutions that are not based on the evidence gathered and are ineffective or cost-prohibitive. |
Our bill demonstrates a superficial analysis of the issue and recommends solutions that are not based on the evidence gathered, ineffective, and unrealistic. |
| Presentation |
We respond thoughtfully to all questions and cite research from a variety of reliable sources. |
We respond to nearly all questions in a thorough manner and cite research from reliable sources. |
We are not able to respond to many questions, and our research sources are limited or not identified. |
We are unable to answer questions, and our research sources are not identified. |