View as Microsoft Word* | View as PDF
Peer Review Checklist
Read and evaluate the claim of the group assigned to you. Make constructive comments and corrections where needed. Check off each item below only if the statement is true. If the claim is not true, use the space provided to offer suggestions to help improve the argument. Use the argumentation rubric as a guide.
Group: __________________________________________________
Reviewed by: _____________________________________________
Claim: __________________________________________________
 |
Claim is clearly stated.
If not, how can the claim be improved?
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________ |
 |
All evidence is clearly explained.
If not, what evidence needs to be clarified?
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________ |
 |
All facts and assumptions are credible and believable.
If not, explain the questionable facts or assumptions.
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________ |
 |
All opposing points of view are accurate.
If not, explain the distorted points of view.
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________ |
< Return to Assessment Plan
< Return to Turning Points in History