Tool Rubric

4

3

2

1

My claim is stated, focused on the topic, and explained.

My claim rating reflects a realistic understanding of the process.

My claim is stated, focused on the topic, and somewhat explained. My explanation does not show full understanding of the topic or claim’s complexity.

My claim rating reflects a somewhat realistic understanding of the process.

My claim is stated unclearly, or it is unfocused on the topic. My explanation is missing or shows a lack of understanding of the topic.

My claim rating is incomplete or unrealistic.

I present a clear and accurate treatment of all available evidence that addresses the central point of the claim.

All evidence is properly documented and assessed.

I present all relevant evidence needed to support the claim with no major errors.

Most evidence is properly documented, and all is properly assessed.

I provide evidence for the claim but do not address all necessary aspects.

Most evidence is properly documented and assessed.

I fail to provide convincing evidence for the claim.

I show a lack of understanding of proper documentation and assessment.

I show an understanding of the complexity of the evidence in relation to the claim.

My rationale of support and nonsupport reflects an understanding of multiple factors and perspectives.

I show a clear understanding of evidence in relation to the claim.

My rationale of support and nonsupport reflects a partial understanding of multiple factors and perspectives.

I show a basic understanding of evidence in relation to the claim.

My rationale of support and nonsupport does not reflect a depth of understanding.

My understanding of the evidence-claim relationship is weak or inconsistent.

My rationale does not support my rating.

My conclusion reflects an understanding of the depth and complexity of the topic based on evidence gathered.

Possible counterarguments are thoroughly addressed.

My conclusion is clearly related to the claim, and described thoroughly and accurately.

My conclusion reflects an understanding of the topic based on evidence gathered.

Possible counterarguments are explained with little detail.

My conclusion is clearly related to the claim

My conclusion reflects some understanding of the topic based on evidence gathered.

Possible counterarguments are only mentioned.

My conclusion is somewhat related to the claim. 

My conclusion is not related to the claim, or it does not show a relationship between the claim and evidence.

Possible counterarguments are not addressed.