< Return to The Case of the Mysterious Malady
Showing Evidence Tool: The Case of the Mysterious Malady
Investigation Rubric

View as Microsoft Word* | View as PDF


Grand Jury Investigation Rubric


4

3

2

1

Preparation and Research: Witness Testimony Our witness statements are scientifically accurate, fully developed, completely consistent with the claim, and accurately portrayed.  

The statements show a thorough understanding of the complex ways in which evidence relates to and supports our claim.  

Our witnesses respond to all questions and keep their answers within the scope of the case.     
Our witness statements are scientifically accurate, adequately developed, fairly consistent, and accurately portrayed.  

The statements show a basic understanding of how evidence supports our claim.  

Our witnesses respond to most questions and keep answers within the scope of the case. 
Our witness statements, questions, and/or performances attempt to show a basic understanding of how evidence supports our claim.  

The statements are sometimes inconsistent and irrelevant.  

Our witnesses attempt to respond to most questions and sometimes keep their answers within the scope of the case.
Our witness statements, questions, and/or performances communicate very little relevant information.  

The statements are inconsistent with evidence supporting or opposing our claim.  

Our witnesses cannot respond to most questions, and they frequently wander outside the scope of the case.
Voice Our speaking is easily understood.  

We consistently speak with appropriate rate, volume, and intonation.    
Our speaking is understood most of the time.  

We speak with appropriate rate, volume, and intonation most of the time.  
Our speaking is sometimes understood.  

We occasionally speak with an inappropriate rate, volume, or intonation.
Our speaking cannot be understood.  

We speak with an inappropriate rate, volume, or intonation.
Authenticity Our portrayals of the characters in the courtroom are very realistic.  

Our body and facial expressions, along with our words and gestures, enhance the meaning of what we are saying.  
Our portrayals of the characters in the courtroom are believable.  

Our body and facial expressions are appropriate and add to what we are saying.
Our portrayals of the characters in the courtroom are somewhat believable.  

Our body and facial expressions are appropriate most of the time.
Our portrayals of the characters in the courtroom are not believable.  

Our body and facial expressions are wooden or detract from what we are saying.
Courtroom Decorum We interact appropriately with others.  

We stay in character and follow courtroom guidelines.     
We interact appropriately most of the time.  

We follow courtroom guidelines. 
We interact appropriately, but at times we seem distracted and unengaged.  

We follow courtroom guidelines most of the time.
We interact inappropriately and seem distracted and unengaged most of the time.  

We do not follow courtroom guidelines. 


< Return to Assessment Plan

< Return to The Case of the Mysterious Malady


Contact Education ›


Terms of Use, *Trademarks and Privacy ©Intel Corporation